The Abundance Trap: What We Lose When Everything Competes for Our Attention

Essay · Antakly Projects

The Abundance Trap

What we lose when everything competes for our attention, told through thirteen voices from our archive.

By Leila Antakly · 2026

0

new tracks delivered to streaming services since you opened this page.Estimate based on Luminate’s 2025 average of about 106,000 a day

You open Spotify on a Tuesday morning, searching for something new. The algorithm offers you a personalised playlist. You scroll. And scroll. Thirty seconds into one song, you skip to the next. Nothing quite lands. You close the app, somehow more tired than when you started. You have access to practically everything humanity has ever created, yet you can’t find anything worth your time.

This isn’t a personal failing. It’s the defining paradox of our era.

Every day in 2025, around 106,000 new tracks were delivered to streaming services, according to the industry data firm Luminate. Nearly half of the 253 million tracks now out there have been played ten times or fewer. Add the hours of video released every week, the millions of books published every year, the artists competing for gallery walls and collectors’ attention, and the endless stream of influencers telling you where to shop, eat, sleep and what to think about it all.

We’re not living in an era of abundance. We’re drowning in noise.

The artists feel it first. Last year the musician Anika told us, without hedging: “I wish Instagram and Spotify didn’t exist.” Ten years ago, almost nobody in our archive would have said that. This essay is about how we got from there to here.

Ten years of our interviews, on the feed

OpenWaryReclaimingRefusing
  1. 2016Paula MendozaInstagram as a “modern ‘art portfolio’”
  2. 2019Ana Jarén“I can reach a lot of different people from all over the world.”
  3. 2019Karolina Muller“Nowadays it’s enough to have Instagram to be a model or influencer.”
  4. 2021Helin Bereket“Art should be accessible to everyone.”
  5. 2021Marco Reichert“Too professional, too clean and too much like a brand.”
  6. 2021Neil Krug“Sensory overload.”
  7. 2021Daniel Clurman“I like to call this my algorithm.”
  8. 2021Cristina Restrepo Lobo“Algorithms have become more important than rhythms in nature.”
  9. 2024Holly North“Algorithms will do the work for our brains.”
  10. 2025Viraj Khanna“We tend to share only our perfect side.”
  11. 2025Anika“I wish Instagram and Spotify didn’t exist.”
01

When everyone can be an artist, what does “good” even mean?

Before social media restructured how culture moves, gatekeepers decided what reached mass circulation. Publishers chose which manuscripts became books. Labels chose who got studio time and distribution. Distributors decided which films got marketing budgets. Curators chose what hung on gallery walls. These gatekeepers were flawed, often elitist, frequently exclusionary. But their filtering created something we’ve lost: a shared understanding of what “good” meant.

The internet promised to democratise art by dismantling these gates. And it delivered. A filmmaker in Lagos can share work with millions without a Hollywood deal. A bedroom producer in Seoul can build a global fanbase without a record contract.

The artists we interviewed in those years felt it. In 2019 the illustrator Ana Jarén told us social media mattered because “thanks to it, I can reach a lot of different people from all over the world.” In 2021 the visual artist Helin Bereket put it even more simply: “I think art should be accessible to everyone — and that’s what I love about social media.” In 2016 the jeweller Paula Mendoza called Instagram her “modern ‘art portfolio’”. The gates fell, and creativity flooded through.

But something unexpected happened in the flood. The model Karolina Muller saw it early, in 2019: “Nowadays it’s enough to have Instagram to be a model or influencer.” When anyone can be anything, the question of what is good gets harder to answer, not easier.

02

The gatekeepers were replaced by algorithms

When the gatekeepers stepped aside, they weren’t replaced by freedom. They were replaced by algorithms. And algorithms don’t care about good. They care about engagement. They prioritise what gets clicked, shared and watched, which often means the emotionally charged, the sensational, the optimised-for-virality. Quality became conflated with popularity. “Good” became whatever the algorithm decided to amplify.

The numbers are stark. By Spotify’s own account, 99.5% of all streams go to tracks with at least 1,000 plays a year; the millions of songs below that line share almost nothing. Most music uploaded today will never be heard by anyone.

Around 2021, the tone in our interviews changed. The German painter Marco Reichert noticed what the feed was doing to artists themselves: some profiles were “too professional, too clean and too much like a brand,” as if their owners didn’t want “to frighten off and lose followers or collectors with their real opinions.” That same year, in East London, the Colombian painter Cristina Restrepo Lobo put it in one sentence:

The world is changing in a way where algorithms have become more important than rhythms in nature.Cristina Restrepo Lobo, 2021

By 2025 the Indian artist Viraj Khanna was making the curated self his subject: “We tend to share only our perfect side of life on social media.”

Black-and-white photograph of Kurt Cobain lying back against a pillow, with the overlaid text: Imagine telling him he needs to make short form content to engage the algorithm
Photo of Kurt Cobain · Grunge Bible

For aspiring artists, this presents an impossible dilemma. There are now two distinct paths: popular, or good in the traditional sense. Being good the old way can take years of study, apprenticeship and the slow development of craft. That path offers no guarantee of visibility, let alone survival.

The question becomes existential. If a song plays in the forest of Spotify and no one streams it, does it exist? If a painting hangs in a studio but never appears in a gallery or a feed, was it made? We’ve achieved the democratisation of creation, but we’re learning that creation without discovery is a tree falling in an empty forest.

Not everyone surrendered the word, though. Asked about his influences in 2021, the artist Daniel Clurman described how he absorbs everything he admires, from history and from social media, and then claimed the word for himself: “I like to call this my algorithm.”

03

How oversaturation changes us

The crisis isn’t only about artists struggling to break through the noise. The deeper cost is what the deluge does to the rest of us: to our capacity for depth, and our ability to connect with ideas and with each other.

In an environment designed for clicks, the pace is lightning-fast. Feeds reward immediate engagement, not sustained reflection. Scroll culture doesn’t just change what we consume; it changes how we think. Many people now find themselves so conditioned by scrolling that they can no longer slow down the way immersive reading requires. Yup, that’s me, and I’ll admit it. The reading brain that once sat with a book, followed a thread, held ambiguity and arrived at insight is, I believe, under threat.

The photographer and director Neil Krug saw this coming in 2021: “In general, it feels as though social media is inundating the world with sensory overload.” He called it “the age of the ‘reactionary’ art form” and predicted it would “in time prove to have overwhelming diminishing returns.” Three years later, the cellist and producer Holly North named the endpoint:

If we stay so predictable in what we like, algorithms will do the work for our brains.Holly North, 2024

When attention fragments, empathy, analysis and long-term thinking go with it. We’re also losing shared culture. The monoculture, when everyone watched the same shows and read the same books, had real problems: it reflected narrow perspectives and excluded many voices. But it gave us common touchstones, a way to talk to strangers, a sense of taking part in something together.

Now culture has split into infinite niches. We’re algorithmically sorted into interest clusters, each fed content that confirms what it already likes. We’re hyperconnected, constantly online and constantly reachable, and yet humanly disconnected. The question isn’t only whether we can get along. It’s whether we can even find each other in the noise.

The abundance doesn’t nourish; it overwhelms.

We’re surrounded by more art, music, film and writing than any generation in history, and we’re starved for depth.

04

Reclaiming depth in the age of infinite scroll

Something interesting is happening in response. Human curation, declared dead in the early internet years, is (I hope) coming back, in forms the old gatekeepers would barely recognise.

The gatekeepers were disrupted, but their function wasn’t eliminated. Tired of algorithmic sameness and AI-generated content that feels increasingly generic, people are looking for the human touch again. Personal taste, the ability to filter and recognise quality, has become valuable in a world drowning in data. Niche newsletters, private communities and physical gatherings like book clubs and listening parties have become antidotes to the feed: places where depth is possible again.

Some artists are refusing the game outright. Anika again:

As a musician, I don’t want to give a single ounce of energy more to thinking about number of plays nor likes.Anika, 2025

Others are inverting the playbook. Fred again.. built a following through surprise, word-of-mouth shows: fans want a piece of the room, not just the record. Kneecap released a film that gave their music context and story, and kept their most devoted fans close through private channels. The lesson from both: success isn’t reaching everyone. It’s connecting deeply with the people who care most.

To be fair to the machine, our archive has its natives too. The political creator Charlie Goldensohn told us about a video that “did millions of views”, and in 2021 the artist Johanna Invrea named a virtual influencer, Lil Miquela, “with her 3 million followers”, as an icon of our time. Platforms can make careers. The question is what they make of the rest of us.

As Stocksy’s culture report on “The Curation Paradox” puts it, “AI struggles with subjectivity. Algorithms operate on quantifiable signals while human aesthetic appreciation is deeply contextual, emotional, and irrational.” Everything starts to look the same because algorithms optimise towards convergence. Human curators can offer what they can’t: context, emotional resonance, and the ability to recognise quality before it has proven itself in metrics.

That last part is personal. I started this platform in 2003, with no ads and no sponsored features, and I have spent more than twenty years interviewing artists before any algorithm decided they mattered.

We’re hitting saturation in unexpected places, too. How many more influencers can tell us where to eat, shop or stay before we tune out entirely? How much longer can everyone online try to convince us of something before we close the apps?

Finishing something, a book, an album, a film, from beginning to end without checking your phone has become a form of resistance.

Would you agree?

05

Living in the tension

We can’t go back to the old gatekeepers, nor should we. More voices can be heard now, and more communities can find and support their artists. But we can’t function in infinite noise either. We’re learning, slowly, that access to everything can feel like access to nothing, and that connection without depth is loneliness with company.

The way forward may be conscious friction: choosing depth over breadth, finishing over consuming, people over optimisation. The algorithm’s goal (keep you scrolling) and yours (find something that means something) are not the same. So seek out filters you trust. Join communities of taste. Support the artists, and the curators, who do the work of making sense of the noise.

In a world of infinite content, attention isn’t just scarce. It’s sacred. Where we put it, what we sit with rather than skim, and whom we trust to guide us are now some of the most important choices we make. The abundance trap is real. But so is our hunger for meaning and for each other, and that hunger might be the signal that guides us through.

You finished it

While you read, thousands of new tracks arrived. You chose this instead.

You might love

Leila Antakly — Antakly Projects
About the founder Antakly Projects · Est. 2003
ciao Milan!
page 48 🫶
VOGUE VOGUE
Vogue Italia
Editorial
Wall St meets
Prada 👜
New York
Finance
this IS the
press release ✨
Film & PR
Disco era
I run this
board 🏄‍♀️
Dubai
Wilhelmina
rosé o'clock
in Madrid 🍷
Madrid
Freelancer & Photo
oat iced latte
and Coco ☕
Washington D.C.
Leila Today
Leila Antakly
Founder, Editor & Creative · Antakly Projects

My career has never moved in a straight line, and that has always been the point. It began in fashion with a formative chapter at Vogue Italia, followed by an unlikely detour into finance. From there, film, PR, events and production. A role as Director at Wilhelmina Models in Dubai sharpened an eye already trained on people worth watching. Then came the years that shaped the platform: writing, editing, producing photo shoots, a short-lived photobooth business, lots of yoga and eventually Madrid, where the light is just right. Currently I am in the States in a new and exciting field, digital marketing for higher ed, but this remains my passion project. What started as a hobby back in 2003 evolved into Antakly Projects, leading to some exciting conversations, projects, and lots of joy. Throughout all of it, my best friend, one small white Shih-poo called Coco, has been present, unimpressed, and very fluffy.

Explore the archive at ninunina.com →

Thank you for following along, for reading these interviews, and for letting them inspire you. And last but not least — for the personal rants on life, opinions you didn't ask for, and the occasional existential spiral: follow me on Substack.

Leila Antakly · Antakly Projects Follow on Substack ↗
Leila Antakly

Leila Antakly is the founder and editor of Antakly Projects, the independent cultural platform she launched in New York in 2003 as Ninu Nina. Syrian and Colombian, she began her career at Vogue Italia and has spent more than twenty years in conversation with artists, musicians, designers, photographers, and inspiring thinkers around the world.

https://www.ninunina.com/
Previous
Previous

ESCARAMUZA: A Book That Captures Magic on Horseback

Next
Next

The Secret Travel List: 10 Cultural Destinations Having Their Moment Before Everyone Else Shows Up