Yes, the traditional art gallery is dying
Kasmin's West 27th Street gallery. Photo by Charlie Rubin
Like everything else right now, the art world is also facing a seismic shift. Since the summer of 2024, a run of high-profile galleries has closed or retreated, leaving artists, collectors and the rest of us asking whether the traditional gallery model has a future, and if so, what it will look like.
In July 2025, Tim Blum announced that BLUM, founded as Blum & Poe in 1994, would close its galleries in Los Angeles and Tokyo after 31 years, moving “away from the traditional gallery format toward a more flexible studio model”, with no permanent public space and no formal roster. Days later, Adam Lindemann closed Venus Over Manhattan after nearly 14 years: “I've seen it from both sides, and now it's time to wave the white flag.”
In August, two more went. CLEARING, founded by Olivier Babin in Brooklyn in 2011 and known for artists such as Marguerite Humeau, Korakrit Arunanondchai and Harold Ancart, closed its New York and Los Angeles spaces, citing “no viable path forward.” “CLEARING was, first and foremost, a shared endeavor, and any success we encountered belongs to all of you,” Babin wrote on Instagram. Kasmin, founded by the late Paul Kasmin in 1989 and home to artists such as Diana Al-Hadid, closed after 35 years and about 350 exhibitions; its president and head of sales reopened as a new gallery, Olney Gleason.
The list kept growing. Stephen Friedman closed its New York space at the end of 2025, two years after opening it, and in February 2026 the London gallery, founded in 1995, went into administration. In April 2026 Templon left its Chelsea space when the landlord pushed for a steep rise on its $55,000-a-month rent. “I feel like it's important for the gallery to have a space in New York,” Mathieu Templon said, “but not at any cost.” Lyles & King and Ross+Kramer are gone too, and Simon Lee has shut. Even Pace, one of the biggest, dropped 50 artists and cut a fifth of its staff.
The closing board
2024 to 2026Nearly 80 years. New York, London, Madrid, Barcelona.
PIVOT1994–2025BLUMGalleries closed; now a studio model, no roster.
CLOSEDc. 2011–2025Venus Over Manhattan“Time to wave the white flag.”
CLOSED2011–2025CLEARINGNew York and Los Angeles. “No viable path forward.”
PIVOT1989–2025Kasmin35 years, about 350 shows. Now Olney Gleason.
CLOSED1995–2026Stephen FriedmanNew York closed in 2025; London into administration.
CLOSEDChelsea, 2022–2026Templon New York$55,000 a month, and the landlord wanted more.
CLOSED2026Lyles & King, Ross+KramerTwo more New York galleries gone.
When the giant fell: Marlborough
If anyone doubted that age and prestige protect a gallery, Marlborough settled it. Founded in London in 1946 by Frank Lloyd and Harry Fischer, with New York following in 1963, it helped define post-war art on two continents. On 4 April 2024 its board announced it would “sunset our nearly 80-year-old firm”, winding down New York, London, Madrid and Barcelona. From June 2024 it stopped holding exhibitions and representing artists (Artnet).
The end had been coming for years: a public feud between the founders' heirs, a fired president, lawsuits that revealed $18.7 million in losses between 2013 and 2019, and the departure of key directors and artists (Artlyst). An inventory reported at over $250 million is being dispersed. This summer, its Chelsea space at 545 West 25th Street sold to Gazelli Art House for $7.5 million.
That room has a place in our archive. In 2011 it hosted Intersection: Photography / Painting / Document, sixteen artists rethinking the photograph, among them my dear friend Ja'bagh Kaghado.
INTERSECTIONRead the 2011 show, revisited ↗So, why are galleries struggling?
- 1Overheads that never stop rising.
Rent is the clearest example: Templon was paying $55,000 a month in Chelsea before the landlord asked for more. Stephen Friedman lost £1.7 million in 2023, partly from paying rent on old and new spaces at once. Add shipping, insurance and staff, and a single major art fair can cost well over $100,000. Josh Baer of The Baer Faxt put the paradox well: “Galleries work on up to 50% margins, yet many barely turn a profit.”
- 2Fairs that are ballooning out of control.
There are too many artworks, too many artists, too many fairs, and they simply cost too much. For mid-sized galleries, fairs are a huge drain. The environmental cost of flying crates and people around the globe is also enormous. And for most visitors, a fair is less about contemplation and collecting than about seeing and being seen.
- 3A changing collector base.
The old guard of collectors is ageing, and younger buyers, though growing in number, don't engage the same way. Many want experiences and community, not a quiet white room and a price list on request.
- 4The artist-gallery squeeze.
A gallery doesn't only sell; it invests in an artist's career, often for years before it pays. When a mega-gallery poaches an artist the moment the market notices them, the smaller gallery that took the risk loses the return.
- 5Burnout.
The old system is being exposed for what it is: a burnout machine that benefits a shrinking few. Lindemann said the “big hugs and air kisses evaporated” the moment he became a dealer, and that he was up against “seasoned veterans with sharpened skills and razor-sharp elbows.”
The galleries that aren't traditional
On a more positive note: what of Hauser & Wirth? I mean, have you seen what they've done in Somerset and Menorca? They have taken the art world to the next level. In Somerset, an entire farm estate is dedicated to art, gardens and food. In Menorca, they restored the 18th-century buildings of a former naval hospital, and opened in July 2021 with a Mark Bradford show and a restaurant run by a local vineyard (Hauser & Wirth). Add their restaurants, and Hauser & Wirth looks less like a gallery than a global luxury brand.
They, too, are guilty of pushing artists to over-produce. But to their credit, they have tied art, travel and hospitality together in an exciting new way.
And that's exactly my point. These aren't traditional galleries. The model that's dying is the one in the middle: a white room, a roster, a booth at every fair, and a rent that rises every year. The galleries that adapt stop being galleries in the old sense.
What survives
The dealers who stay are changing shape. Some are sunsetting their storefronts for private advisory, consultancy and direct-to-audience models. Others are trying:
- Pop-ups and collaborations instead of one fixed, expensive space. Templon now shows by appointment in a private showroom while it looks for a smaller room.
- Shared spaces: galleries splitting a building, and the overhead.
- Community before client lists: talks, performances and dinners that bring in younger audiences, and direct relationships with patrons through subscriptions and artist support schemes such as Collecteurs.
The former gallerist and writer Orlando Whitfield sees a reason for hope in the contraction itself:
“Even though the outlook might seem bleak, there are reasons for optimism. A contraction at the top could result in a market that is less reliant on art fairs and digital interaction. Galleries big and small will then be able to focus on developing closer relationships with artists and collectors on home turf. In too many instances, art and the way it is sold have become indistinguishable from luxury goods. At times it can feel as though the market has forgotten what elevates art and why people want to own it. In my experience as a gallerist, buyers were seeking human connection as much as they were looking to build a collection.”
Orlando Whitfield, “State of the art market”, Monocle, August 2026
So, is this the end?
Our world is changing fast, and we have to keep up. People are fed up and tired. Food is expensive, gas is expensive, war is expensive, and we are waking up to one failed system after another. And the old gallery model, with dealers using it to play with art as an investment, is just one more of them.
The nature of art-world corruption has shifted from forged paintings towards white-collar financial schemes. Three cases show how far trust in the old system has fallen:
One of the most influential New York gallery owners of the 1980s and 1990s was sentenced to 30 months in prison for filing false tax returns, after claiming personal expenses as business deductions. Her galleries closed that spring.
The Art NewspaperThe London- and Miami-based dealer sold shares in the same paintings, including works by Jean-Michel Basquiat and Rudolf Stingel, to several investors at once. He was sentenced to seven years for an $86 million scheme.
US Department of JusticeA New York art advisor to celebrities and collectors, she took clients' money for artworks and used it for her own lifestyle and old debts. She was sentenced to 30 months in prison for a $6.5 million fraud.
US Department of JusticeBut art isn't dying. The white cube in the middle of the market is. What replaces it will be smaller, stranger and closer to people: a studio instead of a showroom, a dinner instead of a fair, a relationship instead of a transaction. The market, like fashion, is cyclical, and more galleries will close. The ones that survive will be the ones that remember why anyone wanted to own art in the first place.
What do you think? Are galleries doomed, or just in need of reinvention?
Photo: Exterior view of Kasmin's West 27th Street gallery. Photo by Charlie Rubin.
Related reading
Explore the full archive. And for the personal rants, opinions you didn't ask for and the occasional existential spiral, follow me on Substack.